Home Page
Archive > Posts > Tags > Searching
Search:

Google Search API Failure
Google Search failed me again

I am once again disappointed by Google Search functionality, which has hindered my implementation of proper searching on this site :-(. (See relevant update).

The Google Search API returns a vastly stripped result set compared to using actual Google Search. I have checked and done a bit of research and have not found a good reason for this. And, no, it has nothing to do with local or personalized searches, which has been confirmed by using searches without any kind of cookies or localizations.

My guess is that the Google Search API and normal Google Search itself are just tapping into different result sets from the start :-(.


An example of this problem is as follows: Searching for “Fractal” in the Projects section returns the following results:

At some point I’ll probably have to find another site search solution for this reason, blegh. :-\

Google Search Removed Functionality
Has Google been removing search options to make things run faster?

I’ve been meaning to get searching working on my site for what seems like forever, and I decided to finally get around to getting some manner of search working via the temporary “use Google” solution. Unfortunately, it seems Google no longer does boolean searches completely properly as advertised. I am sure Google Search still supports boolean logic (as opposed to the assumed “and” between each word) because the Advanced Search, linked to from their front page, still has it, and it returns a few of the results it should.


As an example:
If I wanted to search the Projects and Updates sections of my sites for either the keywords fractal or font I would use the following search:
(site:www.castledragmire.com/Projects OR site:www.castledragmire.com/Updates) AND (Fractal OR Font)

This currently only returns 3 results, when it should return 11 different results, enumerated by using the 4 separate searches (with return results):
  1. site:www.castledragmire.com/Projects Fractal
  2. site:www.castledragmire.com/Projects Font
  3. site:www.castledragmire.com/Updates Fractal
  4. site:www.castledragmire.com/Updates Font

Actual Google returned results: A simple example of this through the Google Advanced Search Page is as follows:

Fractal OR Font site:www.castledragmire.com/Projects [Advanced Search]

Which only returns 3 results (following) instead of the 6 (see above) that it should:

Because of this, I need to go ahead and get real searching up via MySQL (or possibly another solution), as originally planned, sooner than later, since Google will not work as a temporary solution for what I want.


I wrote up a paper on what could be done through Google Search over 5 years ago as a job request [to be posted soon], which I believe is very informative. I’m sure it’s a little outdated, but it shows how much can Google can [could] do for you.